SignUp.com is a great general-purpose sign-up tool for any group — schools, faith, business, sports. Full Turnout is built specifically for youth sports and robotics leagues where families owe hours per player, need verifiable NHS letters, and may forfeit a refundable deposit if they don’t turn up. Different shapes; different jobs.
SignUp.com is a great general-purpose sign-up sheet for any group — schools, faith, business, sports. Full Turnout is built specifically for youth sports and robotics leagues where every family owes a specific number of hours per player, per season, and where one parent with three kids on the roster has three separate requirements tracked independently.
SignUp.com cannot generate community service verification letters. Full Turnout lets volunteers request a signed PDF letter directly from their portal — available on Starter ($10/mo) and Pro plans. Each letter has a unique public URL so NHS chapters, colleges, and scholarship programs can independently confirm authenticity. Volunteers pay $10 per letter; the org pays nothing.
SignUp.com supports collecting payments for events and classes. It does not support refundable volunteer participation deposits — a families-pay-now-and-get-it-back-if-they-volunteer flow that's the standard accountability mechanism in youth sports. Full Turnout Pro auto-refunds when families meet their hours and lets you forfeit unmet deposits at season close.
SignUp.com has basic hour tracking and check-in — they're not feature-empty. If your program just needs a counter for total volunteer hours per person and the simplest possible sign-up sheet, SignUp.com is a fine fit and probably cheaper at small scale. Full Turnout is for when you need the per-player enforcement, the verification letters, and the deposits — and you want those as a system, not bolted together from three tools.
We’ve tried to keep this honest. Where SignUp.com has a feature, we say so — even when it’s a different shape than ours.
| Feature | Full Turnout | SignUp.com |
|---|---|---|
Annual price (typical 100-family league) SignUp.com tiers scale by participant count: $4.99/mo (30) up to $29.99/mo (400). Cheaper than Full Turnout at very small scale; Full Turnout free tier carries unlimited volunteers on the signup side. | Free · $10/mo Starter · $299/yr Pro | $120–$240/yr |
Free trial for paid features | 45 days, no credit card | Free tier (ad-supported, no assistants) |
Public shift signups (no volunteer account) | ||
Slots, waitlists, automatic reminders | ||
Waivers collected at signup SignUp.com gates waivers behind Plus tier ($20.83/mo+). | Premium | |
Multi-organizer / multi-admin | Premium | |
Basic per-volunteer hour counter | Premium | |
Per-player hour requirements within a family One family, three kids on the roster = three independent hour requirements. SignUp.com counts hours per participant only. | Pro | |
Family → player hierarchy | Pro | |
Automatic compliance dashboard (who's behind) See at a glance which families haven't met their requirement and how many days are left to fix it. | Pro | |
Automated low-hours reminder emails | Pro | |
Verifiable community service letters (NHS, college) Each Full Turnout letter has a unique public URL so NHS chapters and admissions offices can independently confirm authenticity. Volunteers pay $10/letter; org pays nothing. | Starter+ | |
Court-ordered service hour documentation | Starter+ | |
QR code check-in / check-out at the event | Starter+ | Basic check-in only |
Hours credit automatically from QR check-in | Starter+ | |
Mobile event-day "sideline" view for admins | ||
Refundable volunteer deposits via Stripe/Venmo Auto-refund when families meet their hours. Forfeit at season close. SignUp.com handles event payments but not refundable participation deposits. | Pro | |
Background check information collection | Pro | |
Season management + one-click rollover to next season Built around the league season as the unit of work — clone roles and defaults to next year while archiving the old one. | ||
Per-volunteer portal (no login, no password) | ||
Custom domain / white label | Coming soon |
SignUp.com pricing and feature tiers based on public information as of June 2026; verify current details at signup.com. Full Turnout: Free (basic signups) · Starter $10/mo (letters + QR) · Pro $299/yr (per-player compliance + deposits).
SignUp.com is a strong fit when you need a general-purpose sign-up sheet and the per-volunteer hour counter is enough. School field trips, PTA potlucks, faith-community service days, office volunteering, scout den meetings — any group where families do not owe a specific number of hours per child, and where nobody needs an NHS letter or a refundable deposit to enforce participation. At small scale, it’s also cheaper.
Full Turnout is built for the youth-sports and robotics use case specifically: one family with three players each owing 10 hours, automatic email reminders when they fall behind, a refundable deposit they get back when they meet the requirement, and a verifiable PDF letter their high-schooler can hand to the NHS chapter. If that’s your world, SignUp.com will get you most of the way and then you’ll end up duct-taping a spreadsheet, a payment app, and an email template on top. Full Turnout is the system that holds all of that.
45-day free trial. No credit card. Set up in under 10 minutes.
Start free — no credit card